REVLON ColorStay Multiplayer Liquid-Glide Eye Pencil, Multi-Use Makeup With Blending Brush, Blends Then Sets, Creamy Texture, Waterproof, Smudge-proof, Longwearing, 404 Under the Radar, 0.03 Oz

All time good reliable brand. Easy to apply. Goes on smoothly and line stays on with minimal bleeding. Very good value and have other colors. Comparable with more expensive brands.

I LOVE this eyeliner! I have fair skin, blond brows and lashes, and hooded, sensitive, contact-wearing, light-colored eyes. With all this paleness, eyeliner is crucial to giving my eyes some definition (I use the color High Stakes). But... just drawing a line close to my top lashes looks so awkward on these blond lashes. I can never seem to get it close enough to the lash line to look natural. This is what I did for SO many years, using every pencil under the sun. I also used the NYX Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner for over a year, going as far as to painstakingly dab it down in between my lashes, which looked nice, but it took forEVER, and then the liner flaked throughout the day.THEN I found a wonderful MUA on YouTube, Lisa J, and she taught me the wonders of tight-lining the upper water line. Totally changes the look for me! It defines the eyes but looks SO natural. If I do it lightly enough, you can't even tell I'm wearing any eyeliner. It's just my eyes but better. I previously using the Wet n Wild Breakup Proof Retractable eyeliner and Milani Stay Put EyelinerBut you MUST have a soft, waterproof, and highly pigmented pencil to make this work. This Revlon "Liquid-Glide" pencil is absolutely PERFECT for this! I can't tell you how smooth this color goes on. I usually sharpen it every 3-4 days, run it back and forth under my lashes on the water line, then smudge it a bit from the outside in with a small brush for a little smokiness (using the Bon-cla Eyeliner Brush, Double-Ended, Combination with Eyeliner for Create Glamorous Eye Makeup, Portable Travel Brush). Once in place for a minute, it doesn't budge. I got this technique from that Lisa J video I mentioned; it's 5 Game Changing Eyeliner Hacks for Small and Hooded Eyes. I really just love her tips!)Caveats:The built-in "blending brush" on this liner pencil is pretty useless (which is why I use the other brush as mentioned above).And this pencil doesn't seem to stay put as well on the bottom lashes (I lightly line just outside the lashes); so I use the Milani pencil for that.Other than those small things, this pencil is IT for me! I hope you find this review helpful because I spent way too much time writing it out, haha!

Beautiful color and stays on!

This is a nice, subtle color. Doesn't drag or pull. I'd like it to stay a bit longer. But it's soft and waxy, so I can't have everything. I've re-ordered it twice.

I've spent $100s over the years on eyeliners that were too waxy to go on smoothly but still got smeary because my eyes water -allergies. This is what I've been searching for. At last!

This pencil is very pigmented but it's also very soft and requires consistent sharpening, almost every time I use it. There is quite a bit of shimmer or maybe even metallic luster to it which is fine if you're into that but I personally wasn't expecting quite this much. The brush on the other end of the pencil is great but I find a normal angled eyeliner brush could be much more effective in the way that I use it. It lasts long but will sometimes rub off on my upper brow bone area which is not an issue I normally ever have other eyeliner. Overall not a bad eyeliner or the price point!

This is the Holy Grail of eyeliners for me. An answer to my prayers. Glides on like a dream, is long lasting and most importantly easily covers the wet line. Stock up now! I did.

I discovered this eyeliner on the website called skin safe that lists beauty product ingredients and gives them scores based on the amount of irritating or harmful ingredients. This was way up on the list as being very hypoallergenic, I never would have bought this because I thought waterproof was the best option for my severe allergy eyes. BUT!! This eyeliner doesn't irritate my eyes AT ALL! IM SO HAPPY!!!😍